The Omicron variant has morphed into greater than half a dozen completely different strains—the most recent of which embody BQ.1.1 and XBB.1, and XBB.1.5. Mixed, these variants and their shut family members now account for practically 90% of new COVID-19 infections within the U.S.
However to date, no COVID-19 vaccine instantly targets them. As an alternative, the most recent bivalent formulation of the booster (and the one one at present accessible) was designed in opposition to the Omicron variants BA.4 and BA.5, that are not extensively circulating.
So how properly does it shield in opposition to the newer ones?
The primary have a look at a vaccine’s effectiveness usually comes from lab-based knowledge analyzing serum from vaccinated individuals, whereas real-world knowledge present how these numbers translate to precise safety and signs of illness. Two new experiences present each sorts of proof—and the very best image but of how the bivalent booster is faring within the face of newer Omicron variants. The upshot? Although the bivalent vaccine was not designed to focus on them, it nonetheless offers some safety in opposition to the most recent variants.
On Jan. 25, the U.S. Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC) reported in its Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report real-world knowledge carried out from December 1, 2022 to January 13, 2023—when the brand new variants have been changing into extra prevalent—displaying that vaccinated individuals who have been boosted with the bivalent shot have been half as doubtless as vaccinated individuals who didn’t get the bivalent booster to grow to be contaminated with these variants and expertise no less than one symptom of COVID-19. On the identical day, in a letter published in the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM), scientists on the College of Texas and Pfizer-BioNTech (which makes one of many FDA-authorized bivalent photographs), reported that the bivalent vaccine nonetheless offers some safety in opposition to BQ.1.1 and XBB.1.
Within the real-world CDC knowledge, researchers present that the bivalent booster is decreasing COVID-19 amongst those that obtain it, and that safety from illness in opposition to the most recent variants is much like that in opposition to the BA.5 variant. That’s “reassuring that the vaccines are persevering with to work,” says the CDC’s Ruth Hyperlink-Gelles, lead writer of the report.
Researchers behind the NEJM paper analyzed knowledge from vaccinated and boosted individuals enrolled within the trials for the unique Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine, who obtained a fourth dose of the unique vaccine, and one other group that obtained three doses of the unique vaccine and a fourth dose of the bivalent vaccine. The researchers had blood samples from the day the contributors obtained their fourth dose, in addition to samples taken one month later, so they might measure antibody ranges in opposition to BQ.1.1 and XBB.1 in the identical individuals.
After one month, individuals who obtained the bivalent booster generated antibodies that have been on common practically thrice larger than these produced by individuals who got a fourth shot of the unique method. “That is the very best [data] you may get on this query in human trials,” says Pei-Yong Shi, professor of biochemistry and molecular biology on the College of Texas Medical Department in Galveston and co-senior writer of the research. “The neutralizing antibody response is clearly higher than [that provided] by the [original] vaccine.”
On this research, the bivalent booster was barely higher at producing virus-fighting antibodies than in previous studies, which discovered solely small variations between individuals boosted with the unique and bivalent vaccines by way of antibodies generated in opposition to BQ.1.1 and XBB.1. (Unpublished knowledge from these teams exhibits equally small variations with XBB.1.5.) In these research, nonetheless, blood wasn’t collected from individuals earlier than and after their fourth booster dose; as a substitute, the scientists in contrast blood from completely different teams of people that had been both boosted with the unique or bivalent doses. A power of the NEJM research is that “you possibly can clearly calculate what’s the contribution of the fourth dose and quantify the variations between the unique and bivalent doses,” says Shi.
Shi additionally notes that in earlier research, scientists used a so-called pseudovirus, which contained solely the spike protein of the virus, to check within the lab how a lot antibody was current within the blood sera. Within the present research, a extra full model of SARS-CoV-2 was used, which doubtless higher mimics what occurs within the physique.
Nonetheless, Shi acknowledges that the response produced by the bivalent vaccine in opposition to the most recent variants isn’t dramatic. “Now we have to acknowledge that BQ.1.1. and XBB.1 actually knock down or evade the antibody response considerably,” he says.
The researchers additionally discovered that the virus-fighting antibody ranges produced by vaccinated and boosted individuals who had recovered from a earlier an infection have been typically decrease than these generated by vaccinated and boosted individuals who had by no means been contaminated, no matter whether or not they obtained the unique or bivalent booster. That might mirror the truth that individuals who have been contaminated have a tendency to begin out with the next baseline of antibodies in opposition to SARS-CoV-2 than those that have by no means encountered any variant.
The underside line is that although the pressure included within the booster not matches the variants at present inflicting infections—and although antibody ranges aren’t very excessive in opposition to the most recent variants—an individual’s whole COVID-19 vaccine historical past continues to play an essential position of their immune response. The unique vaccines taught the immune system to provide long-lasting T cells in opposition to the virus, which helps scale back an individual’s threat of extreme illness. And the bivalent booster seems to be doing its job at maintaining the immune system sharp in opposition to Omicron’s onslaught.
Extra Should-Reads From TIME